Project
2020

Combatting Predatory Academic Journals and Conferences

Policy for Science

Overview

These past two months have seen four regional webinars, delivered in partnership with IAP Regional Networks and the Global Young Academy (GYA), and one global webinar with The World Academy of Sciences (TWAS); all designed to raise awareness of predatory journals and conferences amongst key constituencies.  The webinars attracted interest predominantly but not exclusively from the research community, and post-webinar evaluation polls indicated that the vast majority of participants had improved or significantly improved their understanding of this issue.

The webinars included a short video highlighting the project so far, which is now available below with English, French and Spanish surtitles.   Further materials will be available in the New Year, following publication of the study report.

Predatory journals, publishers and conferences are on the rise and becoming increasingly sophisticated. These practices prey on the pressure researchers feel to publish prolifically, and include pay-to-publish models without peer review, fake editorial boards listing respected scientists, fraudulent impact factors, journal names deceptively similar to those of legitimate journals, and spam invitations to sham conferences with high registration fees.

Indeed, predatory journals and conferences threaten to cause long-term, widespread damage to research and researchers. Although several studies suggest the problem is widespread and increasing, the true extent and impact globally are not known, which makes addressing these practices all the more difficult.  

Led by an independent working group of international experts nominated by academies around the world, this IAP study is gauging the extent and impact of predatory practices, identifying their root causes, and reviewing efforts to combat them. A vital part of the study is a survey for all members of the research community to raise their awareness, and gauge the extent and impact, of predatory journals and conferences across different geographies, disciplines and career stages. The survey ran for two months (November and December 2020) and is now closed. With thanks to all those who participated, infographics representing the survey headlines can be found on the resources tab for this project, with further results being published in a peer reviewed journal in due course. These results are being used to inform recommendations on more effective ways to combat predatory practices and protect researchers everywhere. 

Critically, the IAP study is engaging sister networks - such as the Global Young Academy (GYA), International Science Council (ISC) and The World Academy of Sciences (TWAS) - as well as representatives from all key sectors: research, publishing, libraries and indexing services, universities and international science governance organisations. It is also connecting with other research groups looking at this issue.  Efforts to combat predatory practices in academia must necessarily engage key stakeholders across the globe to effect a concerted, coherent and coordinated approach.  

The IAP study will report in early 2022 and is anticipated to inform a further major study on research evaluation, which lies at the heart of many of the global research community's challenges and for which predatory practices are a symptom.

The following videos contain an introduction to predatory journals and conferences, objectives of the IAP study and results of global survey, key conclusions, recommendations, and next steps as well as common traits of predatory journals and conferences, some guides and tools already available, and a new spectrum approach. English, Spanish, and French surtitles are available.

Project

Updates

People and Institutions

Contact Person

Other resources

This video contains an introduction to predatory journals and conferences, objectives of the IAP study and results of global survey, key conclusions, recommendations, and next steps as well as common traits of predatory journals and conferences, some guides and tools already available, and a new spectrum approach. View here: https://youtu.be/Sp27kzL1TLQ

 

This video contains an introduction to predatory journals and conferences, objectives of the IAP study and results of global survey, key conclusions, recommendations, and next steps as well as common traits of predatory journals and conferences, some guides and tools already available, and a new spectrum approach. View here: https://youtu.be/TtKZ-yEyREU

This video contains an introduction to predatory journals and conferences, objectives of the IAP study and results of global survey, key conclusions, recommendations, and next steps as well as common traits of predatory journals and conferences, some guides and tools already available, and a new spectrum approach. View here: https://youtu.be/o8MEDTtV76Y